How to Set Up Company in Hanoi?

  The Law on investment 2021 has a lot of investment incentive policies in economic sectors in Vietnam for foreign investors.

Foreign investors that invest in Vietnam in general and Hanoi in particular for the first time must have investment projects and fill in investment registration or examination procedures at state agencies in charge of investment in order to be granted Investment Registration Certificates (“IRC”) and Enterprise Registration Certificate (“ERC”). Company with 100% foreign capital has founded and operated from the date of issuance of the investment certificate.

The investor who wishes to apply for IRC in Hanoi, s/he need to have a possible project which is accepted by the Government (The Department of Planning and Investment of Hanoi City). The dossier on applying for IRC
For Investment Registration Certificate, the investor must prepare the dossier included:
i) An application form for execution of the investment project, including a commitment to incur all costs and risks if the project is not approved;
ii) A document about the investor’s legal status;
iii) Document(s) proving the financial capacity of the investor including at least one of the following documents: the investor’s financial statements for the last two years; commitment of a parent company to provide financial support; commitment of a financial institution to provide financial support; guarantee for the investor’s financial capacity; other document proving the investor’s financial capacity;
iv) Proposal for the investment project including the following main contents: investor or method of investor selection, investment objectives, investment scale, investment capital and plan for raising capital, location, duration and schedule of the investment project, information about the current use of land in the location of the project and proposed demand for land use (if any), demand for labor, proposal for investment incentives, impact and socio – economic efficiency of the project and preliminary assessment of environmental impact (if any) in accordance with regulations of law on environmental protection.
If the law on construction requires formulation of a pre-feasibility study report, the investor is entitled to submit the pre-feasibility study report instead of a proposal for the investment project.
v) If the project does not require the State to allocate or lease out land or to permit land repurposing, a copy of the document regarding the land use rights or other document identifying the right to use the location for execution of the investment project is required to be submitted;
vi) Contents of the explanation for the technology to be used in the investment project if the project requires appraisal and collection of opinions on the technology in accordance with the Law on Technology Transfer;
vii) The business cooperation contract if the investment project is executed under a business cooperation contract;
viii) Other documents relating to the investment project, and requirements on the eligibility and capacity of the investor in accordance with regulations of law (if any).
After having the project, the investor needs to apply for Enterprise Registration Certificate, the dossier included:
i) An application for enterprise registration;
ii) The enterprise’s charter;
iii) A list of members of a limited liability company with two or more members or a list of general partners;
iv) A notarized copy of identity card or valid passport of individual member;
v) A notarized copy of the Enterprise Registration Certificate of the organization’s member;
vi) A notarized copy of valid identity card or passport of the organization’s legal representative;
vii) The copy of Investment Registration Certificate.

The time for applying the investment project is 15 working days and the time for applying the company is 03 working days after the date of submitting the valid dossier.

Customers who need advice on setting up a company in Vietnam, please contact the Law firm for the fastest support.

Forms of Foreign Investment in Vietnam

  From 01/01/2021, the Law on Investment 2020 in Vietnam came into force. According to the Vietnam Law on Investment 2020, there are five types of foreign investment in Vietnam.

• Investment in the establishment the economic organizations:

This type comprises two methods: Establishment of a company with 100% capital from foreign investors or establishment of a company between the domestic investors or the domestic government and foreign investors.  Before establishing the economic organizations, the investors must have the investment project, perform the procedures for issuance of the Investment Registration Certificate, satisfy the conditions on the percentage of charter capital ownership according to the Law on Securities, on equitization and transformation of state-owned enterprises, and the other conditions according to the international treaties that Vietnam signed (if any).

• Investment in the capital contribution, purchase shares, purchase contributed capital:

Capital contribution, purchase shares, purchase contributed capital are the types of indirect investment for foreign investors through the purchase of stocks, bonds, and other valuable documents. Investors must conform to the legal provisions on capital contribution, purchase share, and purchase contributed capital.

• Implementation investment project:

Foreign investors can sign the PPP contract. This is an investment method based on limited-term cooperation between the State and private investors through the signing of PPP contracts to attract private investors to participate in the implementation of investment PPP projects.

• Investment under the BCC contract:

BCC contract is signed between the domestic investors according to the Civil Law. BCC contract with at least one party being a domestic investor that performs the procedures for granting the Investment Registration Certificate.

• New forms of investment and economic organizations according to the Government’s rules.

We could assist the client to set up company in Ha Noi, Ho Chi Minh City, Da Nang or in other provinces in Vietnam.

Policies to Attract Foreign Investment in Hanoi

  Over the years, Hanoi city has organized quality conferences of foreign investment attraction, focusing on implementing measures to attract transnational corporations engaged in investment and business in Hanoi.

To perform domestic and international cooperation activities on investment promotion. Hanoi is constantly promoting and improving the efficiency of investment promotion activities, creating a reasonable and effective connection between domestic and foreign investment promotion activities in Hanoi in all fields, economic sectors; connecting investment promotion activities with trade promotion, tourism, and other related activities.

In addition, Hanoi has issued the preferential policies according to priority development groups in each locality based on the advantages and potentials of each locality; innovating the implementation method to well perform the works of attracting, calling and directing foreign investment; renovating mechanisms and policies to attract maximum financial resources from all economic sectors, especially mobilize idle capital from the population to develop production and business.

Hanoi is one of the cities that has favorable business conditions for high technology investors. The improvement of the business environment has greatly contributed to attracting domestic enterprises, foreign enterprises, and corporations to invest in industrial areas in Hanoi. Hanoi not only focuses on developing preferential policies for investors but also promotes the completion of industrial areas, especially high-tech parks. Many FDI enterprises and corporations investing in Hanoi appreciate the improvement of the business environment of Vietnam in general and Hanoi in particular. So the FDI corporations have affirmed that they will choose Hanoi as a place to expand their investment and business in the coming years, especially in the high-tech field.

According to the government in Hanoi, in recent years, Hanoi has become a center of attracting FDI of Vietnam. Currently, this city has more than 6,300 valid FDI projects with a total registered capital is more than 46,8 billion USD. In 2020, despite the Covid-19 epidemic influence, Hanoi still has attracted 4 billion USD of FDI capital and 145,000 billion of domestic capital.

Based on the attracting FDI schedule, from 2021 to 2025, Hanoi will attract 30-40 billion USD of foreign investment capital, in which 20-30 billion USD of disbursed capital. To achieve this goal, Hanoi will promote the investment attraction, focus on the investment in economic infrastructure development, developing the high-tech parks, industrial areas, industrial clusters according to planning, making the investment attraction lists for regions, fields, and products, selecting the investment for the projects using high technology which help the investors could make the investment in the city in an easy way.

Notice of operation of the National Office of Intellectual Property

 

 Due to the recently complicated situation of the Covid-19 epidemic, especially the appearance of new clusters unidentified infections in residential areas, offices, and enterprises, and to implement guidance of the Prime Minister, National Steering Committee for prevention and control, and Ministry of Science and Technology, and the guidance of the emergency dispatch no. 11/CD-UBND dated May 24^th 2021 of Chairman of Hanoi People's Committee on strengthening of measures to prevent and control Covid-19, to contribute to the protection of public health, The National Office of Intellectual Property (NOIP) would like to announce:

From May 27^th 2021, NOIP will stop receiving and releasing results of application for industrial property (IP) at NOIP (no. 386 of Nguyen Trai street, Thanh Xuan district, Hanoi). IP application and dispatches, documents submitted to NOIP office only received through online form or post.

NOIP also stops consulting at NOIP office (386 of Nguyen Trai street, Thanh Xuan district, Hanoi). Accordingly, consulting activities on IP in general and procedure for IP application in particular, only are implemented through telephone or email.

The receipt of application and consulting activities at Representative office of NOIP at Ho Chi Minh city and Da Nang will still go on as usual.

How to Determine Interest Rate for Late Payment Obligations in Commercial Transaction?

  The most important obligation of the parties to a commercial contract is to deliver or provide services and pay in full and on time as agreed. However, in reality, there are times that one party or the parties fail to perform their payment obligations, causing damages to the other party. In particular, in the case of a breach of the payment obligation, the aggrieved party may request the person having caused damage to pay late payment obligations interest.  Potential dispute on this matter might arise between parties.

Article 306 of the Commercial Law 2005 provides for the application of the interest rate due to the delay of payment as follows: Where a contract-breaching party delays making payment for goods or payment of service charges and other reasonable fees, the aggrieved party may claim an interest on such delayed payment at the average interest rate applicable to overdue debts in the market at the time of payment for the delayed period, unless otherwise agreed or provided for by law.

The interest rate for late payment of obligations in commercial business is applied according to the average interest rate on overdue debts in the market at the time of payment corresponding to the late payment period, unless otherwise agreed or otherwise provided by law.

However, the Commercial Law 2005 at that time did not have a specific regulation on the average interest rate of overdue debts on the market. The Resolution No. 01/2019/NQ-HDTP has detailed instructions on this interest rate. When determining the interest on late payments, the Court shall determine the interest rate on late payments on the basis of average interest rates on overdue debts announced by at least 03 (three) commercial banks (such as Vietcombank, VietinBank, Agribank, etc.) whose headquarters, branch or transaction office is located in the same province or central-affiliated city where the headquarters of the Court in charge of the case is located at the payment date (the date of first-instance trial), except otherwise agreed upon by the parties or regulated by laws.

In case of late payment liabilities defined in a contract which includes the parties’ agreement on interest payment, the judgment debtor is liable to pay interest on the outstanding judgment debt at the agreed interest rate which must be conformable with applicable laws; if the agreed interest rate is not available, the Court shall decide application of the interest rate prescribed in Clause 2 Article 468 of the 2015 Civil Code. In case interests are charged on amounts payable to the state budget as regulated by laws, the judgment debtor is liable to pay an interest on the judgment debt arrears calculated at the interest rate prescribed in Article 357 or Article 468 of the 2015 Civil Code, unless otherwise prescribed by laws.

In order to protect the best interest of parties, it is important to consult with dispute lawyers in Vietnam for advice.

What Are the Order of Disciplining Employee in Vietnam?

  

Labour discipline is the provisions on compliance matters relating to work time, technology and production and business management in labor regulations. It can be understood simply that when an employee violates the labor regulations, depending on the extent and regulations of the company, he or she will be subject to disciplinary action. The order of disciplining labor is conducted in accordance with the provisions of labour code in Vietnam. Failing to follow the order of discipline would lead to potential disputes which both employer and employee should consult with dispute lawyers in Vietnam for advice to protect their best interests.

Firstly, the employer must confirm the employee's violations

In the cases where an employee found committing a violation, the employer shall issue an offence notice, inform the employee representative organization (or the employee’s parent or legal representative if the employee is under 18) in order to hold a disciplinary meeting.

Secondly, issuing notice of the disciplinary meeting

This step is only carried out in case the employer detects violations of labor discipline after the time when the violation has occurred, there are sufficient grounds to prove the fault of the employee and the statute of limitations for disciplining.

The employer sends the notice with the content, time and place of the meeting to handle the labor discipline to the organization representing the labor collective at the grassroots level; workers; In the case of a person under 18 years old, there must be the participation of a parent or legal representative.

The employer must ensure these recipients receive notice before the meeting takes place and conduct a labor discipline meeting with the participation of the notification components.

Thirdly, conducting a disciplinary meeting

It is mandatory to have the minutes of the disciplinary meeting, which have to be approved by the participants before the end of the meeting. The minutes shall bear the participants’ signatures. If any participant that refuses to sign the minutes, there should be explanation.

Fourthly, disciplinary decisions

The person that concludes the employment contract on the employer’s side also has the power to issue the disciplinary decision. The disciplinary decision shall be issued before expiration of the original or extended time limit for penalty imposition specified the labour code.

The disciplinary decision shall be sent to the employee (or his/her parent or legal representative if the employee is under 18) and the employee representative organization.

Draft Decree on E-transactions in the Government Management of Land

  In the era of technology 4.0, the application of science and technology in all activities of social life in general is increasingly focused. Vietnam government has introduced a number of policies on the application of electronic technology in administrative procedures, particularly the Draft Decree on Electronic Transactions in the management of land.

Electronic transactions in the government management of land are the implementation of administrative procedures in the field of land; share and provide land information and data; share and provide documents among state agencies.

On the implementation of administrative procedures on land, according to the Draft, the Government stipulates 17 administrative procedures on land to be carried out by electronic methods, such as: land acquisition; land allocation, land lease, change of land use purpose; first registration of land and properties attached to land, first-time certificate of land use rights, ownership of houses and other land-attached assets and additional registration of assets attached to land;... However, in order to carry out electronic procedures, agencies and organizations providing/using electronic transaction services in the field of land must meet certain conditions in accordance with the provisions of this draft.

Regarding sharing and providing information and land data, in the draft, the Government clarified the cases; responsibilities of agencies that share and provide land information and data and responsibilities of land users and users of electronic data. However, the draft did not specify what information allowed to be shared.

The draft also specifies the assurance of security and safety in e-transactions on land and the settlement of arising problems. Accordingly, disputes related to e-transactions in Land areas are settled based on the provisions of the Law on Electronic Transactions, this Decree and other relevant laws. In addition, the draft also provides regulations on the right to appeal, denunciations and regulations on sanctions.

Electronic signatures in the field of land include digital signatures and other types of electronic signatures as prescribed by law. Agencies, organizations and individuals have the right to discuss and select the type of appropriate electronic signature.

The implementation of electronic transaction in the land management will improve the efficiency of land, and real estate transaction from management, development, sales and purchase, and could help reduce the inaccuracy and avoid potential disputes.

What Are Potential Disputes over the Settlement Method for Employees When Separating Enterprises?

 

 In Vietnam, reorganization of an enterprise means the division, separation, consolidation, merger or transformation of an enterprise. In particular, when separating enterprises, in addition to legal issues related to enterprise separation procedures, registration for newly formed enterprises, the introduction of a plan for the employees of the separated company is also a matter of concern. The transferor company and the transferee company need to allocate and use the existing labor force accordingly. It is important to ensure the interests of workers. Specifically, in case of continuing to employ employees, when separating an enterprise, the next employer is responsible for continuing to use up the existing workforce and proceeding with the labor contract amendment and supplement. All of this might lead to potential disputes which lawyers would be involved to provide legal advice from the early stage.

If the enterprise does not use up all the employees or the labor demand of the company does not run out of the existing number of employees, the enterprise must develop a suitable plan to use employees in accordance with the law. Specifically, an employment plan must contain the following main contents: The list and the number of employees to be continued to be used, the employee sent for retraining to continue using; List and number of employees to retire; The list and number of employees who are transferred to part-time work; the employee must terminate the labor contract; Measures and financial resources to ensure implementation of the plan. Enterprises should note that when developing plans for the employment of employees, there must be the participation of organizations representing labor collectives at the grassroots level.

In case it is imperative that the employees quit their job, the enterprise must pay the employee a job loss allowance so that the interests of the employee will still be guaranteed when separating the enterprise. The Labor Code has specified as follows: An employer shall pay a job-loss allowance to an employee who loses his/her job and has worked regularly for the employer for 12 months or longer. The job-loss allowance is equal to 1 month’s wage for each working year, but must not be lower than 2 months’ wage. The working period used for the calculation of job-loss allowance is the total time during which the employee actually works for the employer minus the time during which the employee benefits from unemployment insurance in accordance with the Law of Social Insurance and the working period for which the employer has paid a severance allowance to the employee. The wage used for the calculation of job-loss allowance is the average wage in accordance with the labor contract during 6 months preceding the time the employee loses his/her job.

It is important to have proper and proactive discussion with impacted employee and avoid disputes impacting the company’s reputation.  Dispute lawyers could be of help for advice and preparation.

What Are Penalty for Violations in the Field of Construction in Hanoi?

  In any field, mistakes can occur but differ in actual consequences. Especially in construction activities, the consequences are difficult to predict, the violations in construction activities, to any extent, affect individuals and collective users. Therefore, the Hanoi City People's Council issued Resolution No. 07/2014/NQ-HDND prescribing the fine levels for a number of administrative violations in the field of construction.

This Resolution prescribes the fine levels for a number of administrative violations in construction activities in the Government's Decree No. 121/2013/ND-CP of October 10, 2013 on sanctioning of violations. administration in construction activities; real estate business; exploitation, production and trading of construction materials; technical infrastructure management; housing and office development management (abbreviated to Decree No. 121/2013/ND-CP) in Hanoi city.

The Resolution provides a number of violations and penalties for corresponding acts of investors; of contractors and other organizations and individuals. In particular, the fine level prescribed for an administrative violation in the Resolution is equal to twice the fine level for the corresponding administrative violation in Decree No. 121/2013/ND-CP. The fines prescribed in Chapter II of this Resolution are those imposed on organizations. For the same administrative violation, the fine of an organization is 2 times that of an individual.

The titles competent to impose fines for administrative violations specified in Decree No. 121/2013/ND-CP are competent to impose penalties corresponding to the fines for the prescribed violations. in chapter II of this Resolution. Specifically, the subjects competent to sanction administrative violations under this Regulation include: Construction inspectors; Head of a specialized inspection team; Chief Inspector of Department of Construction; Chief Inspector of Ministry of Construction; Police; Market management; Presidents of People's Committees at all levels

Above are the main contents of Resolution No. 07/2014/NQ-HDND of the Hanoi City People's Council stipulating the fine level for a number of administrative violations in the field of construction, individuals and organizations should grasp to ensure their legitimate rights and interests. For compliance in the area of construction, it is important to consult with construction lawyers in Vietnam for advice.

How Decision 942/QD-TTg on Crypto Currency Would Partly Solve Challenges for the E-Government of Vietnam?

 

 With the strong development of information technology, forms of online transactions has also gradually become a trend and develop strongly in Vietnam. In recent years  crypto currency has created a new phenomenon for the global economy that some countries have been deploying to use such as El-Salvador. However, not all countries accept crypto currencies especially countries such as China, Russia, Thailand... are vehemently opposed to this type of crypto currency for fear of risks to the national economy. In Vietnam, there has been a number disputes involved crypto currency transactions through investment, purchase and sales, which lacked legal framework for resolving, creating challenges for lawyers, and dispute resolving authorities.

The State Bank of Vietnam also has a document prohibiting credit institutions from using crypto currency as a currency or means of payment. However, besides the potential risks, crypto currencies with the advantages of being extremely fast, convenient features which only need an Internet connection and wide application scope should be exploited. Recently, the Prime Minister issued Decision 942/QD-TTg dated June 15, 2021 approving the Strategy for E-Government Development towards Digital Government in the period of 2021 - 2025, with orientation to 2030 pilot using crypto currency. Specifically, the Prime Minister assigned the State Bank to assume the prime responsibility for researching, building and piloting the use of crypto currency based on "blockchain" technology. This is considered a bold step, but it is suitable for the context that illegal "underground" crypto currency exchanges are sprouting up and also opening up a lot of potential for the country's economy.

In fact, in recent years, although the state has issued a document not to recognize crypto currencies, the opening and operation of illegal crypto currency trading platforms  are still common which many Vietnamese people participate. The demand for Vietnamese people to own crypto currency is quite high which crypto currency when approved by the Government will be positively received by Vietnamese people. On the other hand, recently crypto currency has appeared in the media with incidents relating to scams, illegal trading platforms which are not protected by law. But in another aspect, crypto currency transactions also help users perform many purposes such as Hence the Decision 942/QD-TTg issued timely, although still in the testing phase, would partly solve the needs of the economy as well as create strict management and control to protect people. In addition, with the pilot recognition of crypto currencies under the management of the state, it also opens up opportunities for Vietnam to promote the development of new technologies in the e-Government development strategy towards digital government.

Some positive aspects can be mentioned when crypto currency is allowed to be used such as creating convenience in transactions. Specifically, users do not have to go through any stage or intermediary and are not limited, regardless of time and location during the transaction.

Decision 942/QD-TTg also poses many challenges for the Government in management and control. With the "mobility" characteristic, the control of "virtual currency" is not simple, especially for the country which is not yet a highly developed in information technology. Therefore, in order to put "virtual currency" into use, it is necessary to ensure the development of the corresponding technology platform, and at the same time to build a strict legal framework to minimize risks for users. On the other hand, if the "virtual currency" is not well controlled, it will become a money laundering tool, transnational money transferred from illegal co-economic activities such as smuggling, opium, terrorist financing... Another important issue is that our country's Internet system is still unstable. Therefore, in order to be able to circulate virtual money conveniently, it is necessary for Vietnam to further develop the Internet system to ensure stability in transactions.

The crypto currency in Decision 942/QD-TTg shows the Government's aspiration for innovation and determination in moving closer to the goal of national financial inclusion and a digital economy. However, the implementation needs to have a roadmap and orientation as well as a strong legal foundation to ensure effective implementation. Our fintech lawyers at Law company will always follow up with development of legal framework in crypto currency and blockchain technology in Vietnam to provide update to clients.

What Conditions for Arbitration Agreement to Take Effect in Vietnam?

  Commercial arbitration means a mode of dispute settlement agreed by the parties and to be conducted in accordance with law. Arbitration agreement means an agreement between the parties to settle by arbitration a dispute which may arise or has arisen. Dispute is settled by arbitration if the parties have agreed to arbitration.

In order for the arbitration agreement to take effect, what conditions must be met?

The Commercial Arbitration Law 2010 does not specify the conditions for an arbitration agreement to take effect.  However, based on the cases when the arbitration agreement is invalid, we can draw out the basic conditions for the arbitration agreement to be effective.

Parties of the agreement: this condition is considered as the most important when it directly affects the validity of civil transactions in general and arbitration agreements in particular. Accordingly, the person establishing the arbitration agreement has civil capacity as prescribed in the Civil Code 2015.

Jurisdiction of arbitration: the arbitration agreement must belong to the fields under the jurisdiction of the arbitration. Specifically, it is an agreement that requests arbitration to resolve disputes between parties arising from commercial activities; disputes arising between the parties in which at least one party has commercial activities or other disputes between the parties as prescribed by law shall be settled by arbitration.

Arbitration agreement form: the arbitration agreement may be established in the form of an arbitration clause in a contract or in the form of a separate agreement. The arbitration agreement must be established in the form of a document prescribed in Clause 2, Article 16 of the Commercial Arbitration Law 2010, such as an agreement made through communication between the parties by telegram, fax, telex, email or other forms provided for by law; agreement is established through the exchange of written information between the parties; ...

The will of the parties when signing: the parties must be completely voluntary in concluding the arbitration agreement. The parties shall not be deceived, intimidated or coerced in the process of establishing an arbitration agreement. The arbitration agreement violates the prohibition of the law.

In case multiple arbitration agreements are made on the same dispute, the latest lawful agreement shall apply.

Besides, there are many matters that impact the dispute which parties should consider and it is important that parties engage with dispute lawyers early in the dispute stages to review relevant matters and prepare a strategic approach to the dispute for most effective solution.

Questionnaire for Anti-dumping Investigation on Table and Chair Products From the China and Malaysia

  MOIT Issues the Questionnaire for Anti-dumping Investigation on Table and Chair Products From the China and Malaysia (Code of case AD16).

On September 01^st, 2021, the Ministry of Industry and Trade (MOIT) issued the Decision No.2091/QDD-BCT on investigating to anti-dumping measures on some table and chair products origination from the People's Republic of China and Malaysia (Code of case AD16). The Department of Trade Remedies issued an anti-dumping investigation questionnaire on quantity and value for foreign manufacturers/exporters.

Regarding the proposal to extend the time for submitting the questionnaires, the Investigating Authority agreed to extend the time to respond to the questionnaires for the relevant parties. The content of the response will be the same with the following instructions in Official Letter No.683/PVTM-P2 dated September 16, 2021. After the extension period, the Investigating Authority does not receive timely responses from foreign manufacturers/exporters or the information provided is incorrect or incomplete, the Investigating Authority will use information and documents provided by related parties, the information and documents collected by the Investigating Authority or available information and documents for giving the result according to the regulation of Law on Foreign trade management.

The relevant parties must respond to the Investigation Authority before 17:00 November 08^th, 2021 (Hanoi time).

The information, data provided in the Questionnaire of the Investigation Authority and the right to access the information of the case during the investigating term will be implemented in the regulations of the laws.

To ensure its rights and interests, the relevant parties need to answer and submit the Questionnaire on time.

If Client needs any more information or request for legal advice or potential dispute regarding trade remedies measures including, anti-dumping, countervailing duty and safeguard measures or international trade dispute matters, our competition, anti-dumping, and countervailing duty lawyers of International trade and tax practice at ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam always follow up anti-dumping cases and its development to update clients on regular basis.

What Are Regulations on Debt Trading Contracts in Vietnam?

  Along with the development of socio-economic activities, right to collect debt has become an asset right, hence its transferability is also recognized. Vietnam law recognizes debt as a commodity that can be traded through a debt trading contract. However, in order for the debt trading contract to be legally valid and ensure the rights and obligations are enforced, the parties need to pay attention to the provisions on the debt trading contract.

Firstly, in terms of the right to enter into a debt trading contract, according to the provisions of the Civil Code on the sale and purchase of property rights, the property right is the right to claim debt in Vietnam. Accordingly, the right to recover debt becomes the subject of a contract that the parties can transfer as if it were a special type of property. In addition, the debt trading contract aims to transfer ownership of the right of debt recovery and at the same time transfer the debt seller's obligations to the debt purchaser. This is a transaction that does not affect the interests of the debtor totally. Therefore, the transfer of the right to demand does not require the consent of the obligor, whereby the parties can enter into a debt trading contract without the consent of the debtor.

Secondly, in terms of the form of the debt trading contract, based on the provisions of law prescribing debt trading contract by credit institutions and foreign bank branches, debt trading contract is a written agreement on the transfer of the right to collect debt for a debt arising from a lending operation, payment on behalf of the guarantee, whereby the debt seller transfers ownership of the debt to the debt purchaser and receives payment from the debt purchaser. Therefore, the debt trading contract must be made as a written document.

Furthermore, the debt trading contract must be signed by the legal representative or the authorized representative of the debt purchase and sale parties. Therefore, according to this provision, the debt trading contract does not require the parties to be notarized or authenticated. If necessary, the parties can agree on the notarization or authentication of the debt trading contract. In addition, the parties can make an agreement that the contract can be made in a foreign language and the parties need to consent on which language of the contract will be used in case of a dispute arisen. In addition, in case the debt purchaser and debt seller are organizations with legal status, in addition to the legal representative to sign, the contract needs to be stamped. These are strict regulations on the established form to ensure the legality of the contract's form.

Thirdly, when drafting a debt trading contract, it must contains the following principal contents: (i) Time for signing the debt trading contract; (ii) Names and addresses of the parties to the debt trading contract; (iii) Name and title of the representative of the parties to the debt trading contract; (iv) Name and address of the debtor and related parties (if any) to the purchased or sold debt; (v) Details of debt purchased and sold: Loan amount, loan period, purpose, book value of the debt up to the time of debt purchase and sale; (vi) Security measures for the debtor's payment obligation for the purchased or sold debt (if any); (vii) Debt selling price, payment method, payment term; (viii) Time, method and procedures for transferring debt documents and records, including dossiers and documents on debt security (if any); The time the debt purchaser becomes the subrogator, the debt seller has obligations; (ix) Rights and obligations of debt sellers and debt buyers; (x) Liability of the parties for breach of contract; (xi) Settlement of arising disputes. These are the basic and mandatory contents of a debt trading contract. In addition, the parties can make agree on other contents in the debt trading contract that are not contrary to the provisions of the laws.

In addition, during the implementation of the debt trading contract, the law allows the parties to agree to amend, supplement or cancel the content of the debt trading contract. However, the decision to amend, supplement or cancel must be based on ensuring compliance with the provisions of law.

Therefore, the establishment of a debt trading contract in Vietnam is basically the same as other property rights transfer transactions.  However, debt is a special object of property rights, therefore the parties need to strictly comply with the provisions of law on the content and form of the contract to ensure the legality of the contract as well as the rights and obligations of the parties.  It is suggested to engage lawyers with specialization in debt recovery and dispute resolution to assist drafting or reviewing debt trading contract for its effective usage.

If you need legal advice, please contact a Law firm for the fastest support.

How Divorce Procedures Involving Foreign Elements in Vietnam Are Regulated?

  The procedure for divorce in Vietnam involving foreign elements is one of the complicated procedures. Therefore, when implementing this procedures, the parties need to pay attention to the related legal provisions to avoid problems when conducting the divorce procedure in Vietnam or involve family lawyers for assistance in preparing documents and filing petition, especially if there are potential dispute in custody or common assets, properties division.

                                                        Divorce dispute lawyers in Vietnam

Divorce involving foreign elements means termination of the husband and wife relation under a court’s legally effective judgment or decision, in which at least one partner is a foreigner or an overseas Vietnamese or in which partners are Vietnamese citizens but the bases for terminating that relation are governed by a foreign law, or that relation arises abroad or the property related to that relation is located abroad, according to the interpretation on “divorce” and “Marriage and family relation involving foreign elements” of Law on Marriage and family 2014.

The parties when implementing this procedure need to ensure that s/he has the right to request a divorce as prescribed in Article 51 of the Law on Marriage and family 2014. Specifically, the subject of the divorce procedure must be the wife or the husband, or the legal guardian of s/he in the case s/he lost the civil act capacity. The husband has no right to request a divorce when his wife is pregnant, gives birth or is nursing an under-12-month child.

The divorce between a Vietnamese citizen and a foreigner or between two foreigners permanently residing in Vietnam shall be settled at a competent Vietnamese agency.  In case a partner being a Vietnamese citizen does not permanently reside in Vietnam at the time of request for divorce, the divorce shall be settled in accordance with the law of the country where the husband and wife permanently co-reside; if they do not have a place of permanent co-residence, the Vietnamese law shall apply.

The Court in Vietnam has the jurisdiction to settle the divorce request. More specifically, the People’s Court of province have the jurisdiction to settle the case in which involve parties or properties in foreign countries or which must be judicially entrusted to representative agencies of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam overseas or to foreign courts.

The Court will settle the case according to the procedure on code of civil in Vietnam. The time to settle the case will be based on the details of the case. The time limit for trial preparation is from 04 to 06 months from the date the Court accepts the case. The time to set up the court is from 01 to 02 months from the date on which the decision to bring the case to trial is issued. The marriage relationship will terminate from the date the Court has the valid divorce decision.

Besides, the dossier on divorce involving foreign elements including the documents related to marriage relationship, the identification and the documents related to the property, children according to the regulations on Law on Marriage and family 2014 and Code of Civil procedure 2015. In detail, the dossier includes the petition for divorce, the copy of Identification or other personal documents (Passport, Identification card); the copy of Household book, the original of Marriage certificate, in case the parties lost the original of Marriage certificate, the parties could provide the copy of Marriage certificate with the confirmation of competent authority and need to show this information in the petition for divorce, the copy of the birth certificate of the child/children (if having the common child/children); the copies of the documents on the ownership of the property (if increasing the dispute).

In addition, when submitting the dossier on requiring to settle the divorce case: (i) if the parties got married in Vietnam, then the spouse exits abroad (and s/he could not find the address of the spouse), s/he needs to have the confirmation of the competent authority that the spouse existed; (ii) if the parties got married under foreign law wish to divorce in Vietnam, they need to implement the procedure on legalization the Marriage certificate, other related documents, and note in the register book of Department of Justice, then submit the divorce petition. In the case the parties did not implement the procedure on note in the register book but they still wish to divorce in Vietnam, they need to show the reason why they did not make the marriage note.

The person whom submit the divorce petition will submit the dossier to the People’s Court of Province where one of the parties are residing in Vietnam. The Court will check the dossier, if valid, the Court will issue the notification on paying the court fee. After the court fee is paid, the Court will accept the divorce case and issue the notification on acceptance the case to Procuracy, and defendant (the involved parties). Many Courts in Vietnam require the parties to implement the reconciliation step.

It is suggested to involve dispute lawyers if the case of divorce would turns out to be complicated when there are disputes on custody and assets or property division.

How to Determine Penalty and Compensation for Damages from Breach of Commercial Contract?

  When drafting a contract, especially a commercial business contract, in addition to basic provisions such as the object, scope of the contract, value and payment method, rights and obligations of the parties, dispute settlement, information confidentiality, and the regulations on the penalty for a breach of the contract and damage compensation are also very important.

Penalty for a breach of the contract

Under the provisions of the Commercial Law 2005, penalty for a breach means that the breaching party must pay a sum of money to the aggrieved party due to the breach of the violating party if the parties agree in the contract on the fine for a breach. Thus, the penalty for a breach only arises when there is a breach of the contract by the violating party and the parties have agreed on the penalty.

The law gives the right to agree on sanctions for violations to contractual parties, but this freedom to negotiate is limited. Specifically, the parties are only allowed to agree to a maximum penalty of 8% of the breached contractual obligation value, except traders providing assessment services issue assessment certificates showing incorrect results caused by their unintentional faults, they must pay penalty therefor to customers. The penalty level shall be agreed upon by the parties but must not exceed ten times the assessment service charge. In fact, the dispute settlement agency also bases on the prescribed limit of the law to handle; therefore, even if the parties agree to a higher penalty for a breach, it is not applicable in practice.

Compensation for damage

Compensation for damage means a remedy whereby the breaching party pays compensation for the loss caused by a contract-breaching act to the aggrieved party. The basis for arising damages is a breach of the contract; there is material loss and act of breaching the contract is the direct cause of the loss. Difference from penalty for a breach, liability to compensate for damages caused by breaches of contract performance obligations arises even in cases where the parties do not have an agreement on this matter. Besides, the law does not provide any regulation to limit the amount of compensation; it is based on the actual damages that the aggrieved party can prove.

When participating in the transaction, if both types of sanctions are specified in the contract, they should clearly specify the basis for the amount of compensation for the damages and the penalty for violation.

In fact, there are many cases where the parties do not agree clearly or agree on the penalty but the amount of the penalty exceeds the prescribed level, the excess could be considered invalid. The parties should also note that there will be no agreement on late payment interest on the infringement penalty and the amount of compensation damages.

We help clients overcome cultural barriers and achieve their strategic and financial outcomes, while ensuring the best interest rate protection, risk mitigation and regulatory compliance. Law company have Attorneys in Hanoi, Attorneys in Ho Chi Minh and Attorneys in Danang, will help customers conveniently drafting contracts and assist in resolving contract disputes.

How to Apply Exemption from Anti-dumping Measures for Polyester Long Fiber Products?

  On October 19^th, 2021 the Trade Remedies Authority of Vietnam issued Announcement No. 23/TB-PVTM on receiving application for exemption from application of trade remedies for a number of polyester long fiber products (Case No. AD10).

On October 13^th, 2021, the Minister of Industry and Trade issued Decision No.2302/QD-BCT on applying the official anti-dumping measures on long fiber products made from polyester originating from the People's Republic of China, the Republic of India, the Republic of Indonesia (Case No. AD10).

For the basis for considering the exemption request (with restrictions on the volume, quantity of exempted goods, exempted purpose) of the above products, the Trade Protection Department requests the relevant parties that application of trade remedies for a number of polyester long fiber products, contact the Trade Protection Department and provide information:

The scope of the information:

(i) The company's ability to manufacture and supply the products requested for exemption from the domestic company. If it has been manufactured or supplied, please provide detailed information on design capacity, contract and sales invoice of each group of products requested for exemption;

(ii) Opinions and views on the exemption for each of the above product groups.

The products under comments:

First product:

Product: Synthetic filament yarn (combined nylon and polyester yarn) having details as follow:

-Physical characteristics: The yarn cross-section is not uniform due to the fact that it is composed of two different fibers.

-Composition: Combination of polyamide fiber (nylon fiber) (10-30%) and polyester fiber (70-90%).

-Yarn size: 160D/72F; 320D/144F; 75D/36F

-Manufacturing process: Melt polyester yarn at 2600C and polyamide yarn (nylon yarn) at 2200C and then let these two yarns flow through a combination system to form a long yarn composed of polyamide yarn and polyester interlaced yarn interlaced with each other.

-Synthetic filament yarn holding the HS code: 5402.33.00, 5402.46.00, 5402.47.00

Second product:

Product: Synthetic Filament yarn used to produce zippers, includes 03 specific yarn groups as follows: HSY yarn, HTY yarn and HSD yarn having details as follow:

-Physical characteristics:

Shrinkage rate: HTY, HSY yarn: 16% at boiled and 5.5% at dried; HSD yarn: 12% at boiled and 11% at dried

-Yarn size:

100D: PF HTY T1 INA 6K; PF HTY T1 INA-2 6K;

150D: 150/48*2 GPOASY (recycle); DTY 150D/48F/2 SDR (recycle); PF HSY T1 INA; PF HTY T1 INA

250D: PF HTY TL INA; PF HTY TL INA-2;

300D: PTY SD T1 ABR; PTY SD T1 MBR; PTY SD T1 MBR HSD; PTY SD T1 MBR2 HSD; PF HTY T1 INA; PF HTY T1 INA-2

450D: PTY SD TL MBR;

500D: PF HTY T1 INA; PF HSY T1 INA; PF HSY T1 INA-2; PF HTY T1 INA-2

The period of comment:

The information will be sent to Trade Protection Department before December 20^th, 2021.

If Client needs any more information or request for legal advice or potential dispute regarding trade remedies measures including, anti-dumping, countervailing duty and safeguard measures or international trade dispute matters, our competition, anti-dumping, and countervailing duty lawyers of International trade and tax practice at ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam always follow up anti-dumping cases and its development to update clients on regular basis.

Extend the Response Time to Apply Anti-dumping Measures on H-shaped Steel Products From China

  On October 29th, 2021, Department of Trade Remedies issued the Investigation Questionnaire on the review and application of anti-dumping measures on H-shaped steel products originated from China for the relevant parties in the case ER01.AD03.

For facilitating conditions for relevant parties to fully cooperate in the case, the Investigating Authority extends the time to response the questionnaire for relevant parties. After the extension period, if the Investigating Authority does not receive timely responses from the relevant parties or the information provided is incorrect or incomplete, the Investigating Authority will use information and documents provided by related parties, the information and documents collected by the Investigating Authority or available information and documents for calculation and evaluation according to the regulation of Law on Foreign trade management.

The relevant parties must respond to the Investigation Authority before 17:00 December 20^th, 2021 (Hanoi time).

The information, data provided in the Questionnaire of the Investigation Authority and the right to access the information of the case during the investigating term will be implemented in the regulations of the laws.

If Client needs any more information or request for legal advice or potential dispute regarding trade remedies measures including, anti-dumping, countervailing duty and safeguard measures or international trade dispute matters, our competition, anti-dumping, and countervailing duty lawyers of International trade and tax practice at ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam always follow up anti-dumping cases and its development to update clients on regular basis.

Extension of Response for Cane Sugar Anti-Dumping Case

  Extension of Response for Foreign Manufacturers and Exporters and Domestic Manufacturers and Importers for Cane Sugar Anti-Dumping Case(Case No. AC02.AD13-AS01)

On September 21^st, 2021, the Ministry of Industry and Trade issued Decision No. 2171/QD-BCT on investigating the application of measures to prevent evasion of anti-dumping measures to a number of cane sugar products originating from Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia and Myanmar.

On October 25^th, 2021, Department of Trade Remedies (Investigating Agency) announced on the issuance of the Investigation Questionnaire for Foreign Manufacturers and Exporters and Domestic Manufacturers and Importers (Case No. AC02.AD13-AS01).

During the process of receiving the Investigation Questionnaire, the Investigating Authority received requests to extend the time for answering the Investigation Questionnaire from the relevant parties. Therefore, on November 23^rd, 2021, the Investigating Agency issued the announcement on agree to the extension. The Investigating Authority requires all relevant parties to cooperate and participate sufficiently during the investigation. The extent of the response will be the basis for the Investigating Authority to review and draw a conclusion of the investigation of this case. In the event that the Investigating Authority does not receive timely responses from relevant parties or the information provided is incorrect or incomplete, the Investigating Authority will use information and documents provided by related parties, the information and documents collected by the Investigating Authority or available information and documents for giving the result according to the regulation of Law on Foreign trade management.

The relevant parties must respond directly to Investigation Authority before 15:00 on December 16^th, 2021 (Hanoi time).

The information, data provided in the Questionnaire of the Investigation Authority and the right to access the information of the case during the investigating term will be implemented in the regulations of the laws.

If Client needs any more information or request for legal advice or potential dispute regarding trade remedies measures including, anti-dumping, countervailing duty and safeguard measures or international trade dispute matters, our competition, anti-dumping, and countervailing duty lawyers of International trade and tax practice at ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam always follow up anti-dumping cases and its development to update clients on regular basis.

How Foreigners Can Extend Visa in Vietnam During Covid-19?

  

Since the beginning of 2020, due to the impact of the Covid-19 epidemic, many foreign nationals entering Vietnam on a visa-free basis, entering with an e-visa or a tourist visa have been "stuck" in Viet Nam. In addition, Vietnam is restricting the issuance of new visas to foreign citizens to focus on the prevention of the Covid-19 epidemic, hence many foreign citizens in Vietnam cannot apply for a new visa, even though their visas have expired. Many foreigners have been concerning whether they can extend visa in Vietnam and seek help from immigration lawyers in Vietnam for such queries.

To ensure the legal residence of these foreign citizens during the time when the world is facing the Covid-19 epidemic, Vietnam has "automatically extended temporary residence" status for foreign citizens in the above categories from March 01^st, 2020 to the end of December 31, 2021. Foreign nationals who are automatically extended temporary residence do not need to apply for a new visa, however, they will renew their temporary residence every month to legally reside in Vietnam.

The automatic extension of temporary residence is also applied to cases of entry before March 01st, 2020 if they can be proven to be stranded due to the Covid-19 epidemic, certification of the Diplomatic missions by Diplomatic note (with Vietnamese translation) or a written certification from a Vietnamese competent authority about being isolated, treated for Covid-19 or other force majeure reasons.

In addition, to be automatically extended temporary residence, foreign citizens eligible for automatic extension of temporary residence must make temporary residence declaration and medical declaration according to regulations. In addition, foreign citizens need to comply with and not violate the law in Vietnam.

Automatic extension of temporary residence will help foreign citizens save time, cost, and travel restrictions during the outbreak of the pandemic as complex as it is today. However, the extended period of temporary residence is normally 30 days, hence the foreigners need to carry out the procedure to extend their temporary residence every month according to the notice of the Immigration Department.

In cases of extension of temporary residence, foreign citizens are allowed to temporarily reside in Vietnam for the permitted period and exit without declaration. After exiting the country, if they wish to return to Vietnam, foreign citizens must apply for a new visa in accordance with the law.

Plan to Simplify Regulations on Telecom, Gaming, Internet Service

  In the process of economic integration and development, in order to create favorable conditions for business and service sectors under the management of the Ministry of Information and Communications, Vietnam has approved the plan to reduce and simplify regulations a number of regulations under its control.

Accordingly, Decision No. 1994/QD-TTg agreed to reduce and simplify regulations related to business lines: Provision of pay radio and television services; Provide G1, G2, G3, G4 video games online; Newspapers; Telecommunications service business; publisher's activities; Business in printing services, except for packaging printing; Publishing services business; Postal services; Information Technology; Science and technology; Domain name registration and maintenance services; Internet; Network information security products and services in Vietnam.  It is important for the company operating in the areas of concern to consult with telecom, internet business, media lawyers to follow up with specific changes in law in Vietnam.

These are industries with fast-growing trends and have a strong impact on other industries as well as on the overall economic development. Therefore, the facilitation and restriction of procedures will contribute to attracting foreign investment and creating development motivation for businesses, quickly catching up with the rapid changes of services, improving the quality of services and improving the quality of services information and communication products.

Accordingly, on procedures for granting certificates of eligibility to provide public electronic game services, for the application components "Plan for the location of the computer room of the public video game service point suitable according to the prescribed area" and "Pay the fee for the issuance of the Certificate of eligibility to operate the point of supply providing public video game services" were abolished. Especially, it is subject to change immediately after the time of licensing. Therefore, the information of the location of the machine room option at the time of consideration for licensing is of little significance. Besides, the Decision also mentions supplementing the form of implementing administrative procedures on electronic means (changing the form of paper copies into electronic ones) to be flexible and ensure consistency with the Enterprise Law 2020 in the implementation for businesses.

The decision also abolishes administrative procedures for granting licenses to provide G1, G2, G3, G4 video game services online. According to the plan, many procedures with G1 online game service will be abolished such as: licensing procedures; license re-issuance; license renewal or procedures for amending and supplementing the license to provide G1 video game services on the internet... This is a meaningful abolition decision for the practice of licensing video games. Because, it is challenging for state agencies to request enterprises to apply for permits and report every time they change their business plans, affecting the autonomy of enterprises as well as creating huge inadequacies in terms of business administrative procedures.

In addition, business conditions: "The publisher's office has an appropriate area, meets the provisions of the law on standards and norms for using the office" has been simplified to " having an office that meets the provisions of law on standards and norms for using the office”. This change is reasonable, because the criterion of suitable area has no basis for explanation. Moreover, the area of ​​the publisher's headquarters is not related to the management of the State. With the new regulations, publishers can be autonomous in choosing the right area, ensuring space for business activities. At the same time, the Decision also combines two administrative procedures including re-issuance and renewal of licenses for printing and publishing publications into one administrative procedure, limiting cumbersome procedures, saving time and costs for businesses.

In addition, in the field of publication distribution service business, the Decision simplifies the process of granting certificates of registration for publishing and publishing electronic publications in the direction of only performing the verification process determining the project of publishing and distributing electronic publications. Therefore, if the project is eligible and accepted, the enterprise will be granted a certificate of operation registration immediately.

According to the simplified version of the Decision, the Postal Business Registration Certificate and the Postal Investment Certificate in Vietnam will be merged into the Business Registration Certificate.

Therefore, the introduction of Decision No. 1994/QD-TTg has reduced and simplified procedures; help the process of preparing documents quickly; save time for organizations and individuals when carrying out administrative procedures and minimize the cost of administrative compliance.

Public Hearing of Investigating and Applying Anti-Dumping Measures on Polyester Filament Yarn (AD10 case)

 On April 6 2020, Minister of Ministry of Trade and Industry signed the Decision 1079/QD-BCT in the case of investigating and applying anti-dumping measures on Polyester Filament Yarn originating in the People's Republic of China, the Republic of India, the Republic of Indonesia and Malaysia (AD10 case).

Pursuant to Article 70, Law on Foreign Trade Management 2017 and Article 13, Decree no. 10/2018/ND-CP stipulated the details of some articles of the Law on Foreign Trade Management on trade defense measures, the Investigation Authority is going to hold a public hearing for AD10 case.

Specifically, the hearing will take place online via Meeting room no. 904 – 23 Ngo Quyen, Hoan Kiem, Hanoi at 9am – 12pm, August 30^th, 2021, by Hanoi time. The spoken and written language used in the public hearing is Vietnamese. The related parties have the right to use other languages, however, translation from that language into Vietnamese is required. Information and documents other than Vietnamese provided by the related parties must be translated into Vietnamese. The related parties must ensure the truthfulness, accuracy and responsibility before the law for the translated content.

Deadline for submitting registration and consultation content will be before 5pm, August 23^rd, 2021 by Hanoi time.

If Client needs any more information or request for legal advice or potential dispute regarding trade remedies measures including, anti-dumping, countervailing duty and safeguard measures or international trade dispute matters, our competition, anti-dumping, and countervailing duty lawyers of International trade and tax practice at ANT Lawyers, a law firm in Vietnam always follow up anti-dumping cases and its development to update clients on regular basis.

What Bona Fide Possession of Property Are and How the Rights Are protected?

  Possession in good faith means the possession that the possessor has bases to believe that he/she has the right to the property in Vietnam under his/her possession. Bona fide possessor is protected by the law on property rights. Owning this type of property might be subject to many potential disputes which parties should consult with dispute lawyers from time to time to understand his/her rights to the property.

According to Clause 3 Article 184 of the 2015 Civil Code, a person possessing in good faith, continuously and overtly shall be eligible for prescriptive periods for enjoying the rights and enjoy the yield and income derived from the property as prescribed in this Code and relevant laws.

A person possessing in good faith is entitled to protect his/her rights and his right to possession when meeting specific conditions. Before a third person entered into a civil transaction, a prior civil transaction was established, the previous civil transactions were invalidated. Besides, the third person establishing civil transactions must be honest. Property traded in accordance with law and civil transactions must be compensated.

The owner has the right to reclaim the property from the rightful owner in accordance with Article 167 and Article 168 of the Civil Code 2015. Accordingly, depending on the type of property subject to ownership registration or not, the reclaim of ownership of the owner has a certain difference. Specifically, owners may reclaim movable property not subject to ownership right registration from bona fide possessors in cases where such bona fide possessors have acquired such property through unindemnifiable contracts with persons who have no right to dispose of the property; in case of indemnifiable contracts, the owners may reclaim the movable property if such movable property has been stolen, lost or other cases of possession against the owners' will.

Owners may reclaim their movable property subject to ownership right registration and immovable property, except for cases where a civil transaction is invalid but the transacted property is registered at a competent authority and such property has already been transferred to a bona fide third party through another transaction which is established according to that registration, such transaction shall remain valid.

In cases where the transacted property which is required to be registered has not registered at a competent authority, the transaction with the third party shall be invalid, except for cases the bona fide third party received such property through an auction or a transaction with an another party being the owner of such property pursuant to a judgment or decision of a competent authority but thereafter such person is not the owner of the property as a result of the judgment or decision being amended or annulled.